How to Use the New YouTube Comments with Google+

By Tico+Tina

Last updated January 13, 2014


Tico+Tina is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases also at no extra cost to you.

I’m not internet-stupid. Seriously. But it still took me a while to figure out how to use the new YouTube comments with Google+. At first I was all like, uhhhhhhhhh it’s broken?!?! I finally sat down to sort it out a couple days ago.

There are many (legitimate) concerns about how Google is taking over everything and forcing people to do things a certain way and too up in everyone’s business and completely ignores their users…

I have all of these concerns, and a particularly BIG beef with their major lack of good communication. I mean, I’ve spent countless hours trying to figure out how to work around this or that update, integration, account madness… which is finally starting to get sorted out reasonably! Too bad I’ll never get that time back.

However, I completely agree with the change in the way YouTube now does comments. I don’t have a problem with Google+ because it’s eons better than Facebook, and it only makes sense for video comments to become integrated. It does take some getting used to, though.

New YouTube Comments Pros

  • You can now include links in comments!
  • It’s harder for people to comment anonymously (you need a legit YouTube account or a Google+ account). This should cut down somewhat on trolling, although if you visit the comments of the video above you’ll see that there is still plenty of hate going on 😉
  • Cut through the crap comments – uploader comments and the best comments will be on top. YouTube had already kind of started doing this, but now it seems it will be better.
  • You can now have a private discussion about a video with a friend by choosing Public versus just adding a friend or two.
  • You can also tag people in your public comments.
  • Edit your comments, just like in Google+. I know some people don’t agree with being able to do that, but I personally think it’s great. You can also delete your comments now.
  • You’re no longer limited to short comments! Personally I like this one because I can be a bit verbose 🙂
  • Blacklist words and phrases you don’t want to have showing up in your comment section and they will automatically be blocked. (You can also black list users, but you could do that before I believe.)
  • You can choose to disable replies to your comment if you want to for some reason.
  • You can easily share your comments to Google+

New YouTube Comments Cons

  • All old comments made before the new system are just kind of stuck there – no one can reply to them, even channel owners where the comment was made!
  • The old way you were used to seeing your comment notifications, whether on your videos or replies to your comments no longer works properly. You’re notified via Google+ notifications instead. There are some definitely glitches with this but I expect it will be sorted out.
  • You now have to uncheck the “share to Google+” any time you make a new comment on a video (not to replies) if you don’t want it automatically shared.
  • You can now leave links in comments… yes, this is in the cons as well as pros because spammers will be even more motivated, haha.

The navigation for YouTube has been a mess for years – I couldn’t figure it out when we started, and it seems they just keep adding navigation in new, confusing places (the navigation is completely different depending on which page you’re on, and you can’t get everywhere from one page, but rather have to dig to find things). Eventually I’m sure it will become unified with a proper interface, but Google does things at its own, behemoth pace… I actually see changing over the commenting system as a step in the right direction with fixing the confusing navigation – after everyone gets used to it, that is.

Workaround for Replying to Old Comments

So basically, if you come across comments that you aren’t able to reply to, even as a channel owner, they are legacy comments in the old system. You can reply to many people of those people (because it’s a Google+ function) by making a new comment and just adding the + in front of their user name and it will show up in their notifications.

Basic Overview of New YouTube Comments

Where to see comment notifications:

new-youtube-comments

Where to blacklist people and words:

youtube-blacklisting

Comment Options

youtube-plus-google

youtube-comment-options

What do you think about the new system?

We're well-acquainted with being stuck in soul-sucking survival mode, and the intense internal friction of not living in alignment with your potential. We're all about discovering, creating, and sharing adulting cheat codes™ so you can level up faster! -David (Tico) & Chris(tina)

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Streamline the essentials;
activate your potential.™